Academy/Membership & Annual Meetings
Nominations
How a name legally gets onto your board's election ballot.
A nomination is how a name gets onto the ballot for a board seat, whether it comes from a nominating committee's slate or from a member on the floor. Under Robert's Rules, floor nominations stay open before the vote even with a committee slate, and a nominee needs no advance consent, only eligibility for the office.
Two ways a name gets on the ballot
Most associations appoint a nominating committee that proposes a slate before the annual meeting. That slate is a starting point, not the final list. Under Robert's Rules of Order Newly Revised (RONR), the parliamentary authority most HOA bylaws name by default, a floor nomination (a nomination made by a member from the meeting floor rather than through the committee's slate) has to stay available at some point before the election happens, committee or no committee.
"even if a nominating committee is in place, under Robert's Rules, nominations from the floor are in order at some point before the election is pending."
Source: Candidate Nomination, FindHOALaw
A floor nomination also doesn't need the chair's permission to happen or a second member to back it up. Any member in good standing can simply stand up and name a candidate.
Saying yes isn't required, only being eligible
A common assumption is that you can't nominate someone who hasn't agreed to run. Under RONR, that's backwards. The only thing that has to be true at the moment of nomination is that the person qualifies for the office.
"The nomination is valid provided the nominee is qualified for election to the board; the nominee need not be contacted in advance of being placed on the ballot."
Source: Candidate Nomination, FindHOALaw
In practice, most boards still check with a nominee before the meeting so nobody is surprised, but that courtesy is a habit, not a rule.
What Robert's Rules doesn't decide
A candidate statement (a written statement a candidate submits before the meeting so members can review it before voting) feels like standard election machinery, but RONR itself says nothing about one. Its length, its deadline, and whether one is required at all come from somewhere else entirely.
Whether your association requires a candidate statement, how long it can be, and when it's due depend on your state's election statute, if one exists, and your association's own election rules. Check your governing documents before you tell a candidate what's expected of them.
Check yourself
Answer before you read the explanation, recalling it is what makes it stick.
A nominating committee presents a slate of three names for three open seats. A member then stands and nominates a fourth candidate from the floor. What happens?
A member nominates a neighbor for treasurer from the floor, but the neighbor is out of town and never agreed to run. Is the nomination valid?
A board member insists, "Robert's Rules requires every candidate to submit a 250 word statement before the election." Is that accurate?
Sources
- Candidate Nomination, FindHOALaw
- Robert's Rules: Nominations from the Floor, Dummies.com, C. Alan Jennings, PRP
- Robert's Rules of Order Newly Revised, official FAQ, Robert's Rules Association
- Robert's Rules of Order Newly Revised, Official Interpretations, Robert's Rules Association
Related elsewhere in the Academy
Membership & Annual Meetings
Ready for the moment a name actually gets called out at the microphone? See how floor nominations play out in real time.
Whether a candidate statement is required, its deadline and length, and whether your bylaws limit or prohibit floor nominations all vary by state and by your governing documents.