Academy/Parking, Roads & Vehicles
Towing
The self-help remedy with the sharpest teeth, and the strictest rules for using it.
Towing a vehicle from your community is one of the riskiest self-help actions a board can take. State law, not just your bylaws, governs it, often requiring exact signage, advance notice, or written authorization. California punishes a defective tow with a misdemeanor and four times damages. Confirm your state's private-property towing statute before authorizing a tow.
Towing is self-help, not a court order
Towing is one of the few enforcement tools an association can carry out without asking a judge first: the vehicle is gone as soon as the authorization is signed, before the owner has any chance to respond. That speed is exactly why towing statutes exist, to stop an association from removing a car casually or without warning.
Whether your association can tow at all, and under what conditions, depends on authority spelled out in your recorded declaration, not on a rule the board adopts on its own. Authority to enter or act for one purpose does not automatically extend to another, so check what your declaration actually says about towing specifically before relying on a general enforcement clause. See Self-help for how that principle works across self-help remedies generally.
What a towing statute can require: California as a worked example
There is no single national towing rule. California's private property towing law is unusually detailed, and it is useful here as an illustration of how exacting a statute can get, not as a stand-in for your own state's rule.
"post signs of regulation size and content at all entrances to the development warning that public parking is prohibited and that unauthorized vehicles are subject to tow at their owners' expense"
Source: How to Tow, Berding & Weil LLP
Without that signage in place, California instead lets the association issue a parking violation notice at least 96 hours before towing. Either path also requires specific written authorization naming the vehicle, the grounds for the tow, and when the violation was first observed.
"the association (through its board of directors) can be guilty of a misdemeanor punishable by a fine of up to $2,500 and/or imprisonment... for up to three months"
Source: How to Tow, Berding & Weil LLP
On top of that, the association can owe the vehicle owner four times the towing and storage charges. Treat those numbers as a preview of what a state can attach to a defective tow, not the figure your own statute uses.
What to confirm before you authorize a tow
- Your state's private property towing statute: what signage, notice, or advance warning it requires before a tow is lawful.
- Any local ordinance your city or county layers on top of state law.
- Whether your declaration actually authorizes towing, and for what circumstances specifically.
- Written, specific authorization naming that one vehicle, never a standing blanket approval to tow on sight.
Without a court order behind it, a self-help remedy like towing is also weaker in practice than it looks: police generally will not enforce a declaration's self-help clause on your behalf, and an owner who disagrees can call the police themselves. Confirm the paperwork before the tow truck arrives, not after.
Check yourself
Answer before you read the explanation, recalling it is what makes it stick.
A board tows a car blocking a fire lane without checking any signage or notice rules first, in a state with a strict towing statute. What is the board's biggest exposure?
The declaration lets the board enter a lot to maintain the landscaping. Can the board use that same clause to tow a resident's car from their driveway?
A board member wants to know the exact notice period required before a vehicle can be towed. Where should they look first?
Sources
- How to Tow, by Sandra M. Bonato, Esq., Berding & Weil LLP
- Can the HOA Trespass to Correct Violations?, quoting attorney Debra Oppenheimer, HindmanSanchez, published by ECHO
Parking, Roads & Vehicles
Read Self-help next to see how the "check your declaration first" rule applies beyond towing, to any enforcement action your board takes without a court order.
Towing notice periods, signage requirements, and penalties for a defective tow vary by state and often by local ordinance. The California figures on this page are one worked example, not a national standard.